The Peoria Park District’s Mission is “to enrich life in our community through stewardship of the environment and through provision of quality recreation and leisure opportunities.”
Doug Stewart, Peoria Journal Star:
Reaction was quick and varied to the Peoria Park District’s decision to hold qualifying for the Peoria Men’s City golf tournament from the back tees at Newman Golf Course.
Predictably, better players had no issue with the move and mostly were in favor of it. The average players, including a number of seniors who couldn’t handle the added length, disagreed with the decision and many of them withdrew from the qualifying round.
But more important than the addition of a few hundred yards, the change planted a seed that could forever alter the format of central Illinois’ oldest golf championship. Because when tournament director Terry Ridgely said “this is a championship, designed to find the best player in the city,” those words stirred up a hornet’s nest of controversy.
“Great idea, But he didn’t go far enough,” Tim Anderson said from behind the counter at Illini Golf. ‘If they want a true championship, they should eliminate the lower flights and just have a 64-player tournament. We have enough hit-and-giggle events around here. The City doesn’t have to be one of them.”
Hit and Giggle? Wow. That’s rough. The Championship flight of the Men’s City usually has a cut in the mid 70’s for 64 players, then has 32 more in each of the A, B, & C flights, of which the latter usually has a cut in the low 80’s. I don’t believe most people who can shoot in the low 80’s tend to “hit and giggle” and those who can’t go that low mostly don’t even try; more power to those that don’t have the game and try. Mr. Anderson should think before he speaks, as I am one of his customers and one who, when I had the time to practice, regularly shot in the low 80’s. A hack to him, I’m sure, but above average to most.
Although my game is not up to snuff to enter the City this year, qualifying from the Blue tees was long overdue, but getting rid of the lower flights is a horrible idea. There is already a championship where only the best players even consider entering and that’s the Peoria Stroke Play Championship. For many years I entered the City, qualifying in various flights. Most memorably was a semi-final match that I lost on the 18th hole. I was in C flight at Newman; I don’t recall the exact qualifying score that year, but it was probably around 82/83, which isn’t too shabby for us weekend hackers.
Regarding this…
“This tournament always is a money loser for us,” {Newman GC head pro Dustin} Martin said. “Our daily play, especially later in the week when there are just a handful of matches, is always bigger than what we do in the City.
Obviously I don’t have daily play stats, but I can say that personally, when I planned on playing in the City, I’m going to be practicing and playing a lot more frequently than normal in the time leading up to the qualifying and matches. Take away the lower flights for people like me who can shoot in the low 80’s and you’re taking away a lot of rounds.
One could argue that the better players have season passes and more rounds do not mean more revenue, but I would counter with a personal observation that I haven’t had a pass in several years and therefore I don’t stick to Park District Courses when I get the opportunity to get out, but I do play either Newman or Kellogg regularly as tournament time approaches. Cutting the lower flights would only add to the ‘flight’ to the many and varied courses out of town.
The ‘City’ is a wonderful tournament. I applaud the move to the blue tees for qualifying and think it is long overdue, but if they drop the lower flights, I guarantee they will regret their decision. Rounds played will continue to drop and during the week of the Men’s City, the average golfer will still avoid the host course during that time.
Peoria is a great golfing town and the Men’s City is a great tournament composed of people of all ages and from all walks of life.
Let’s not screw this up.